Welcome to Unsifted | Your go-to source for #modernmilling and fresh flour baking!
0 Cart
Added to Cart
    You have items in your cart
    You have 1 item in your cart
      Total
      Check Out Continue Shopping
      Blog Menu
      freshly milled peanut butter cookies, whole wheat peanut butter cookies, unsifted peanut butter cookies

      Fresh Milled Peanut Butter Cookies

      So, you're craving a sweet treat that's nutty, buttery, and oh-so-delicious? Look no further, because we've got the perfect recipe for you! Get ready to whip up some fresh flour peanut butter cookies that will have your taste buds doing a happy dance.

      Our peanut butter cookies are creamy and boast the delicious Unsifted Dessert Blend's mild pastry flour goodness!

      They are a simple and scrumptious recipe for making the perfect peanut butter cookies. Get ready to impress your friends, family, or just yourself with these delectable treats.

      Happy Unsifted baking!

      Sarah + Keira

       

      Unsifted® Peanut Butter Cookies 

      **Prefer a hard copy? Checkout the beautiful professionally printed recipe card for Peanut Butter Cookies COMING SOON!**

      PREP: 15 minutes
      TOTAL: 30 minutes 
      YIELD: 25 cookies

       

      INGREDIENTS

        1 cup

      Unsifted®  Dessert Blend

        ½ cup

      unsalted butter, softened

        ¾ cup

      creamy peanut butter

        ⅓ cup

      granulated sugar

        ⅓ cup

      packed brown sugar

        1 large

      egg

        2 tsp

      vanilla extract

        1 tsp

      baking powder

        ½ tsp

      salt

        ¼ cup

      granulated sugar, for finishing (optional)

       

      INSTRUCTIONS:

       

      1.  Mill the fresh flour

      • Preheat oven to 375F
      • Set WonderMill® dial to “Pastry”
      • Mill 1 cup Dessert Blend

      2.  Mix butter + sugars

      Pro Tip: Butter softened past room temperature or overmixed can cause flat cookies. If final dough is shiny, place in fridge to harden.

      • In a mixing bowl, add ½ cup softened butter
      • Add ¾ cup peanut butter
      • Add ⅓ cup sugar
      • Add ⅓ cup brown sugar
      • Mix using an electric mixer on high speed until smooth and slightly fluffy (about 1-2 minutes)

      3.  Add wet ingredients

      • Add 1 large egg
      • Add 2 tsp vanilla
      • Beat well

      4. Add dry ingredients

      • Add 1 tsp baking powder
      • Add ½ tsp salt
      • Mix well

      5.  Mix remaining ingredients

      • Add all unsifted flour 
      • Optional: Add mix-ins (see variations on recipe card)
      • Mix until just combined (do not overmix!)

      6.  Chill dough (optional)

      • Cover dough with plastic wrap
      • Place dough in refrigerator for 1-2 hours or up to 3 days

      7.  Shape + Bake

      • Lightly grease baking sheet or use parchment paper
      • Shape dough into 1 ½ Tbsp balls
      • Optional: Add ¼ cup sugar to small bowl and roll each dough ball in sugar
      • Place on baking sheet, 2” apart
      • Using a fork, flatten ball making a crisscross pattern
      • Bake at 375F for 8-10 minutes
      • When cookie edges are barely browned, remove baking sheet from oven to avoid dry cookies
      • Let cookies rest about 10 minutes on the baking sheet
      • Using a spatula, transfer cookies to a wire rack to cool, or serve and enjoy warm

      STORAGE TIPS

      Cooled cookies may be stored in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 5 days, or frozen for up to 3 months in a freezer bag. Thaw at room temperature before enjoying.

      ****Find our delicious Bakery Style, Chocolate Dipped, Natural Peanut Butter, Nutter Butter® Homemade Cookie VARIATIONS on our hard-copy recipe card that is COMING SOON****

      Share your #modernmilling creations! Tag @unsifted.kc

       If you try this recipe please leave a comment and tag @unsifted.kc

       

       

       

       

      freshly milled oatmeal cream pie recipe; fresh flour oatmeal cream pie, freshly milled flour oatmeal cookie

      Freshly Milled Oatmeal Cookies (+Oatmeal Cream Pies!)

      So, you're craving something sweet, huh? How about sinking your teeth into a heavenly oatmeal cream pie? These little treats are the perfect combination of chewy, creamy, and oh-so-satisfying. But wait, we're not talking about just any oatmeal cream pie here.....we're talking freshly milled flour oatmeal cookies which takes these babies to a whole new level of deliciousness. Get ready to have your taste buds dancing!

      If you're new here, you might be wondering, "What's the big deal with using fresh flour?" Well, my friend, freshly milled flour is like the secret ingredient that takes your baking game to new heights. It adds a depth of flavor and a softness to your oatmeal cream pies. Trust us, once you try it, there's no going back to regular old flour.

      Unsifted® Oatmeal Cookies are a delightfully soft, chewy, fresh milled dream!  These cookies use all olive oil too so they are perfect for anyone trying to use less butter!  This original recipe was gifted to me from my Father-in-Law (thank you so much!!) and it's currently my younger son and my favorite recipe to make together.  He calls them "the sandwich cookies". 

      Read more

      fresh milled flaky biscuit. fresh milled buttermilk biscuit

      Fresh Milled Flaky Biscuits

      These Unsifted FLAKY BISCUITS are so so delicious. Personally, I like to be able to separate them into a few flaky layers...BUT I still want it to be tender.  I need a little bit of both. We love these biscuits plain, with gravy, sweetened and with strawberries, and with chocolate chips and a simple vanilla drizzle.  These biscuits pass the husband and kid test at my house and I hope you love them too :)

      Read more

      Fresh Milled Snowball Cookies

      Fresh Milled Snowball Cookies

      These Unsifted Snowballs are a buttery, toasted pecan shortbread-like cookie that is the perfect bit-sized treat. Once they’re rolled in powdered sugar they look like little snowballs. They only have a few ingredients so they mix up easy and freeze beautifully to make party prep a breeze! 

      Read more

      Red Velvet Cake

      Red Velvet Cake

      Tis the season for red velvet cake and cupcakes! Sarah is an avid red velvet fan, and truth-be-told I usually don't seek it out.  That being said, I am a very big fan of the recipe below!  I'll be transparent, this is not a standard southern red velvet cake with subtle vinegar tang.  But it's similar and boasts a delicious moist crumb with just slightly more chocolate than normal, while still letting the cream cheese frosting have the starring role.

      Read more