Welcome to Unsifted | Your go-to source for #modernmilling and fresh flour baking!
0 Cart
Added to Cart
    You have items in your cart
    You have 1 item in your cart
      Fresh Milled English Muffins

      Fresh Milled English Muffins

      These Unsifted®  English Muffins have been a long time coming! I'm delighted to share that these have a spongy texture, nooks and crannies, are easy to make AND are absolutely delicious.  Plus, you don't need any special mixers or bread machines to whip these up. My family loves to make breakfast sandwiches with eggs, cheese and bacon or sausage on these. They are filling and perfect for all ages. 

      I know so many of you have been asking for the recipe for SO long.  Thanks for your patience! I couldn't settle for using our standard Simple Sandwich recipe and just cooking it on the skillet. To be honest, it's taken me about 4-5 complete restarts to get this recipe to a place where I feel excited to share it.  So many of the attempts I tried and continually tweaked were delicious.....BUT they were often just a basic dough cooked on the skillet. They were soft and fluffy inside...but that doesn't match the store-bough English Muffins I was trying to replicate.

      One important note that I'd like to make is about the ingredients list.  When you look through the recipe you'll notice it calls for arrowroot powder. This is an important ingredient for texture, so I don't recommend subbing or skipping it. 

      Checkout our reel on Instagram @unsifted.kc to get a visual overview of these beauties.  All the details are below but in short, it's basically just:

      • Mill the fresh flours
      • Mix the dry ingredients
      • Mix the wet ingredients
      • Knead until its tacky
      • Press out and separate balls
      • Let rising
      • Cook on a skillet
      • Let them cool for an hour (this is important!)
      • Open with a fork and enjoy!
      I highly recommend freezing any extras you may have to make for easy weekday breakfasts.

      Happy Unsifted baking!



      Unsifted® English Muffins 

      **Prefer a hard copy? Checkout the beautiful professionally printed recipe card for freshly milled English Muffins COMING SOON!**

      PREP: 50 minutes
      TOTAL: 2 hours 30 minutes 
      YIELD: 15-18 muffins


        3 ¼ cups

      Unsifted®  Basic Blend

        2 Tbsp

      whole popcorn, for finishing

        ¼ cup

      arrowroot powder

        2 tsp


        2 tsp

      instant yeast

        2 Tbsp


        1 ½ cups

      water (lukewarm)

        ½ cup

      whole milk (lukewarm)

        1 ½ Tbsp

      olive oil

        2 tsp

      apple cider vinegar



      1.  Mill the fresh flour + popcorn flour

      • Set WonderMill®  dial to “Pastry”
      • Mill 3 ¼ cups Unsifted® Basic Blend
      • Set aside ¼ cup unsifted flour in a small bowl
      • Add remaining unsifted flour to medium mixing bowl
      • Set WonderMill®  dial to “Course”
      • Mill 2 Tbsp popcorn + set aside in a small bowl for finishing
        (Note: If you are not using the WonderMill®  we recommend you read your owners manual to ensure it can handle milling popcorn)

      2.  Add dry ingredients

      • Add ¼ cup arrowroot powder
      • Add 2 tsp salt
      • Add 2 tsp instant yeast
      • Mix well to combine

      3.  Add wet ingredients

      Pro Tip: This dough should be tacky, but not overly sticky.  The less flour added the lighter and softer texture will result.

      • Add 2 Tbsp honey
      • Add 1 ½ cups lukewarm water
      • Add ½ cup lukewarm milk
      • Add 1 ½ Tbsp olive oil
      • Add 2 tsp apple cider vinegar
      • Using dough whisk or hands, mix well until smooth texture and holds shape (about 3-5 minutes)  Note: May add 1-2 Tbsp of flour, if needed

      4.  Shape the dough + Rise

      Pro Tip: Be careful to not overproof dough, ensure that the dough is still rounded on top. If it is flat or spread thin, it is over proofed.

      • Prepare sheet pan for dough to rise- do grease and do NOT use parchment paper
      • Lightly dust counter with remaining unsifted flour (or use olive oil) to prevent sticking
      • Separate dough into 15-18 rounds- do this by either weighing ~70g each and shaping into a tight disk OR flatten all dough to be approximately 1” thick then use 3” biscuit cutter to make circle rounds
      • Dip bottom of dough into popcorn flour to prevent from sticking to pan
      • Optional: Dip topside of dough lightly into popcorn flour
      • Set directly on sheet pan, ugly and popcorn covered side down, about 3 inches apart
      • Cover balls loosely with plastic wrap
      • Let rise until doubled or passes the poke-test (about 25-45 minutes)

      5.  Cook on skillet + Cool for 1 hour

      Pro Tip: Don’t be tempted to cook the muffins on a higher temp. or the nooks and crannies won’t develop as much.

      • Preheat skillet(s) on low heat
      • Using spatula, carefully transfer muffins ugly side down onto preheated skillet (no butter/oil on skillet)
      • Cook for 8-12 minutes until bottom is light brown
      • Gently flip to other side and cook for additional 4-8 minutes until browned (200-205F internal temp.)
      • Let cool on cooling rack for at least 1 hour to allow nooks and crannies structure to setup
      • Use fork to open each muffin to get maximum nooks and crannies



      Cooled English Muffins may be stored at room temperature in an airtight container for up to 5 days or frozen for up to 3 months. Do NOT store in the refrigerator, as this will make it go stale faster.



      Find our delicious VARIATIONS + TIPS on our hard-copy recipe card that is COMING IN THE FUTURE.

      Share your #modernmilling creations! Tag @unsifted.kc

       If you try this recipe please leave a comment and tag @unsifted.kc



      Fresh Milled Hawaiian Sweet Rolls

      Fresh Milled Hawaiian Sweet Rolls

      Here's our Unsifted recipe for Hawaiian Sweet Rolls.  Afterall, who doesn't love the Hawaiian Rolls from the store? My family sure did....but I felt so many carb consequences whenever I ate them from the commercial, lifeless flour.  Good news! Unsifted has the solution for you! It took many attempts, but I finally created a recipe that my family loves and that has a soft yet rich texture.  It uses the technique from our Unsifted Japanese Milk Bread recipe (Coming Soon!) and combines that with all the delicious flavors for Hawaiian Sweet Bread. Use our recipe below and learn how to make your own fresh, Unsifted Hawaiian Sweet Rolls that are not only healthier but also tastier than anything you can find on the shelves.

      Read more

      Tuscan Focaccia

      Tuscan Focaccia

      This is the BEST bread recipe for beginners, hands-down! You don’t need a mixer and there’s no kneading required. It only takes 5 minutes to stir together and it can sit in the fridge for up to 3 days – it’s ready to bake whenever you are! This focaccia is a Tuscan dream for your tastebuds, perfectly crisped on top with delicious garlic + rosemary infused olive oil. It’s pronounced “foh-kah-chuh” and will have you saying “fab-u-lous!” The thick, spongy texture is perfect for dipping in soup, using for pesto slab sandwiches, serving with pasta, topping like a pizza, or curating your charcutier board.

      Read more

      Fresh Herb Stuffing

      Fresh Herb Stuffing

      Unsifted Stuffing is a Thanksgiving must-have that is sure to impress! Your favorite fall flavors are paired with the unmatched nutrition of Unsifted Fresh Flour to make the ultimate comfort food. This savory, buttery, holiday classic is baked to perfection with a light crisp on top and a soft, moist center.

      Unsifted Stuffing is versatile enough to handle bread cubes that are stale, toasted, or fresh - or try using a combination! You can even get creative by mixing a variety of bread types (we highly recommend Unsifted Simple Sandwich Bread paired with Focaccia…recipe coming soon!). The different textures add a delightful twist to this family favorite.

      Read more

      Homemade Pitas, Whole wheat pitas, Fresh Flour Pitas

      Fresh Flour Pita Pockets

      Fresh Flour Pita Pockets exceeded my every expectation and are now a monthly staple in our meal planning schedule. Between the delicious fresh flour taste, the soft pliable pocket, and the warm tender goodness, we can't get enough! Quick. Easy. Delicious. Yes please!

      This recipe also includes a light and fresh Greek Salad filling that you HAVE to try! Especially if you have extra cucumbers from your garden, this recipe is CALLING your name! 

      Read more